https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doxastic_logic
Something i read long time back when i read Smullyan's books, but making a note because i love it. His types of reasoners is beautiful :)
Something i read long time back when i read Smullyan's books, but making a note because i love it. His types of reasoners is beautiful :)
Types of reasoners[edit]
To demonstrate the properties of sets of beliefs, Raymond Smullyan defines the following types of reasoners:
- Accurate reasoner:[1][2][3][4] An accurate reasoner never believes any false proposition. (modal axiom T)
-
- A conceited reasoner with rationality of at least type 1 (see below) will necessarily lapse into inaccuracy.
- Consistent reasoner:[1][2][3][4] A consistent reasoner never simultaneously believes a proposition and its negation. (modal axiom D)
- Normal reasoner:[1][2][3][4] A normal reasoner is one who, while believing also believes he or she believes p (modal axiom 4).
- Peculiar reasoner:[1][4] A peculiar reasoner believes proposition p while also believing he or she does not believe Although a peculiar reasoner may seem like a strange psychological phenomenon (see Moore's paradox), a peculiar reasoner is necessarily inaccurate but not necessarily inconsistent.
- Reflexive reasoner:[1][4] A reflexive reasoner is one for whom every proposition has some proposition such that the reasoner believes .
- If a reflexive reasoner of type 4 [see below] believes , he or she will believe p. This is a parallelism of Löb's theorem for reasoners.
- Unstable reasoner:[1][4] An unstable reasoner is one who believes that he or she believes some proposition, but in fact does not believe it. This is just as strange a psychological phenomenon as peculiarity; however, an unstable reasoner is not necessarily inconsistent.
- Stable reasoner:[1][4] A stable reasoner is not unstable. That is, for every if he or she believes then he or she believes Note that stability is the converse of normality. We will say that a reasoner believes he or she is stable if for every proposition he or she believes (believing: "If I should ever believe that I believe then I really will believe ").
- Modest reasoner:[1][4] A modest reasoner is one for whom every believed proposition , only if he or she believes . A modest reasoner never believes unless he or she believes . Any reflexive reasoner of type 4 is modest. (Löb's Theorem)